WEEKLY SOUTHERN ARTS
"Sometime the boogaloo 
  • Home
  • Guns, Faith and Murder
  • The Million Dollar Store
  • Artistic Con-cepts
  • Judy Garland - "Soul Singer"
  • Robert & Jimi and the Twenty Seven Blues
  • The Great Pretenders
  • Imagine
  • Me and Junior Parker
  • The Republican
  • Sweet Home Chicago (The Obama Shakedown)
  • The Ballad of Hunter & Joe
  • The 22-yr-old Bottle Blonde
  • Is It Alright...To Be White?
  • Resist the Devil and He Will Flea
  • Music & Reminiscence
  • Lowell George searching for authenticity
  • A Telling Lie
  • Part One: The Monster Is Summoned
  • Like Billy Eckstein Singing to an Empty Club at 1:00 AM on a Saturday Night in 1975.
  • Bent
  • Kelly Joe Phelps
  • Why The Devil Don't Come Around No More
  • Hearing Junior Wells “On Tap'' one more Time
  • Muddy and Me
  • American Youth: The Rise of The New Media
  • Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Talk About Slavery and Shit
  • Just Smoke
  • The Big Maybe
  • The Skinny
  • Florida in Images and More Images
  • "Muthafuckin' Chains!"
  • The Inner Man
  • This is Not a Political Article
  • A Tale of Wine and Murder
  • Jesus Was a Sly Dog
  • The Existential Croûton
  • The Prison Yard Blues
  • Conspiracy Theory
  • 4 More Poems, 4 More Pictures
  • "Are You Freaking People Insane?"
  • 4 Pictures 4 Poems
  • The Ballad of Carlos Slim
  • Pretending What's in Your Head is True
  • The Cognitive Dissonance of a Faithful Democrat
  • The Human Snakepit
  • George Freeman - Unsung Master of the Jazz Guitar
  • The Price of Milk
  • Suspicious Minds
  • Bill O'Reilly Sexual Predator?
  • The New Soldier
  • Orwell Revisited
  • Larry Coryell - The Godfather is Dead
  • A Tiger Beat
  • South Florida - HOT & COOL
  • Jean Paul Sartre & the Existentialist Mojo
  • Culture Matters, Immigration Matters, Sharks Matter
  • Thomas Sowell
  • A Tree Falls In Central Park on a Gay Banker
  • Black Codes From The Underground
  • Man Talk, with Donald Trump pt. 1
  • Man Talk, with Donald Trump pt. 2
  • Brexit Was the Shot Heard Around the World
  • I Love The Dead
  • The Game
  • Goodbye Scotty Moore
  • If a Bluebird Plays the Blues Why Can't it Play Free Jazz
  • When David Slew Goliath
  • Why Cream still Matters 50 Years Later
  • Goodbye Lonnie Mack
  • Black Lies Matter, All Lies Matter
  • The Folly of Foibles
  • The Life of an Imaginary Historian
  • Angel: part 7
  • Wayne Cochran "Going Back to Miami"
  • The Last Damned Healthcare Article You'll Ever Need
  • The Gospel According to Mark
  • Angel: part VI
  • Ted Bundy & The Hunt For The Devil
  • Charlie & Clint: Dead & Deader
  • Trayvon & George : An American Hate Story
  • Jury Duty
  • Little Tommy & The Blues Kings
  • Kayaking "The Big Cypress" with Crocodlies
  • The Birth of The Jazz Guitarist
  • Gay Marriage
  • Garage Band - The 1960's
  • King Arthur, Pelagius and Original Sin
  • The Story of Ricky
  • Hidden Miami
  • I Hate the 60's: A Personal Rock Odyssey
  • Crocodiles and Alligators in Florida: Monsters in our Backyard
  • The Legend of Robert Pete Williams
  • Saturday Night At Big Tinys
  • The Case Of The Infinite Monkeys
  • The American Heritage Series
  • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress
  • Blue And Green

              Heroes and Dunces

Picture
Bill Maher denigrated the American people as dunces who lack nuance. At least, that's his take on all the people who liked the film “American Sniper” me included. Talk about a lack of nuance! He takes a few of Chris Kyle's comments out of context and determines that he must have been a jerk, certainly not a hero.

Let's say that Kyle could be a jerk, maybe even a major jerk. Does that mean he couldn't also be a hero? What is Maher really saying, that “Real heroes” must be politically correct, or culturally tolerant of the enemy, including their use of civilian men, woman and children as suicide bombers? Who, by the way, were trying to kill Kyle and his fellow soldiers.  But, apparently, that's only because those poor Iraqi snipers and death squads were defending themselves against Americans occupying their country.  Saddam Hussein was obviously a well loved leader and honorable man, not a psychopath at all. And besides, who are we to call someone a psychopath?  Maher, however, does exactly that when talking about Kyle. Why?  Because he has all the nuance of a man who fell out of a tree and hit every branch on the way down.


Let's be clear about something, if Chris Kyle had served in WWII, no one would be calling him anything other than an American Hero, but he didn't.  He served in an unpopular war.  And, to acknowledge his actions in a positive light is to reaffirm the Iraq war and possibly even the Bush administration--and that will never do.  That, however, is a different debate. 

Unfortunately, it never seems to dawn on Maher that judging a man who served four tours of duty, protecting American lives by shooting enemy combatants, could reasonably be engaged in a heroic and noble cause, even if the war itself was morally questionable.  If, at times, Chris Kyle could be a jerk, the two are hardly mutually exclusive. 
Do we really want angst ridden soldiers on the battlefield, questioning the morality of every situation they find themselves in? I don't think so.  Winston Churchill, for instance, was known to be arrogant and abrasive. Few would reasonably argue, though, that he wasn't instrumental in saving England and  probably all of Europe from Hitler and the Nazis.  His character flaws, relatively speaking, were of little concern. 

Maybe, it's that Kyle was a sniper?  Should Kyle have engaged the Iraqis in hand to hand combat?  Maybe, that would've been brave. Of course, t
hat would have also been a remarkably inefficient way of protecting his fellow soldiers and inevitably led to far more American deaths, probably more Iraqi deaths, as well.  Or, maybe, Bill Maher is simply another idiot talking about something he knows nothing about. The latter seems a whole lot more likely.

There is plenty of room to question America's role in various wars. That is the nature of democracy. But, Maher doesn't really do that. He stakes out familiar territory from the very comfortable position of a wealthy, privileged observer. One who's superior morality cost him nothing. For others, though, the cost is everything.  Most Americans, moreover, most rational people, understand this and honor those who made the necessary sacrifice.  And, that hardly makes them naive.


Mark Magula

    Please Enter Your Comments Below: